Published on October 5th, 2023

Why Does My Neighbor Pay Less Property Taxes?

Unveiling the Property Tax Enigma - The Mystery of Neighborly Disparities

Aventine Properties | 3 min read

Property taxes can vary significantly from one homeowner to another in New York State, leaving many wondering why their neighbor might pay less. Several factors contribute to these discrepancies, shedding light on the complexity of property tax assessment and the variations in tax burdens between properties within an area..

1. Property Valuation and Assessment

The primary reason your neighbor pays less in property taxes could be differences in property valuation and assessment. Properties are assessed periodically, and the assessed value forms the basis for property tax calculations. If your neighbor's property is assessed at a lower value than yours, they will naturally pay less in property taxes. Discrepancies in assessment can occur due to variations in property size, home style, and condition. Comparing areas to each other, neighborhood reputation can also play a role.

2. Tax Exemptions and Abatements

Another factor that can lead to differences in property tax payments is tax exemptions and abatements. Some homeowners may qualify for tax breaks or reductions based on factors such as age, income, or property usage. For instance, senior citizens may be eligible for property tax exemptions, effectively reducing their tax burden. Understanding the available exemptions and abatements can help homeowners take advantage of potential savings.

Start Saving Money

File A Tax Grievance With Aventine Before the Deadline

3. Local Tax Rates

New York State's property taxes are not uniform across the state. Different municipalities and school districts set their own tax rates, which can vary significantly. If your neighbor lives in an area with a lower local tax rate, they will naturally pay less in property taxes, even if their property's assessed value is similar to yours. It's essential to consider both the assessed value and local tax rates when comparing property tax bills.

4. Property Improvements and Renovations

Home improvements and renovations can also impact property taxes. If your neighbor has invested in energy-efficient upgrades or made substantial improvements to their home, they may be eligible for tax incentives or exemptions related to those improvements. These incentives can lead to lower property tax bills, even if the assessed value remains the same.

5. Appeal Process

Lastly, it's worth noting that the property tax assessment can be appealed. If you believe your property has been overvalued, you can go through the appeal process to request a reassessment. If your neighbor successfully appealed their assessment and had it reduced, this could explain the lower property tax bill.

In conclusion, the differences in property tax payments between you and your neighbor in New York State can be attributed to a combination of factors, including property valuation, tax exemptions, local tax rates, property improvements, and the appeal process. It's essential to understand these factors and, if necessary, consult with local tax authorities to ensure that your property taxes are assessed fairly and accurately.